When the Christian asks, "What if you're wrong, and there's a God, and you have to spend eternity in hell because you didn't believe?" An atheist replies, "What if you're wrong, and there's a God, and you have to spend eternity in hell because you did?"
God, who makes us just broken and ignorant enough to be dependent upon a highly flawed power-seeking church of men for our salvation, no matter how many inquisitions or pedophiles it employs, is angered enough to throw us into hell for all eternity for having the courage to go it alone.